• Am I The A’hole? (AITA)
  • (AITA) I was sitting in the parking lot outside the pharmacy when my phone buzzed.

    I was sitting in the parking lot outside the pharmacy when my phone buzzed.
    MyAccount Tasks: Helping Your Student Complete Enrollment - Becoming Biola - Biola University
    It was a message from my ex’s wife, Mia.
    There was a photo attached.
    I opened it, and the world around me went a little quiet. Cars moved past with their turn signals blinking, someone pushed a cart across the lot, a kid complained about not getting candy, but I just sat there with my thumb on the screen, staring.
    In the picture, my daughter, Ellie, and Mia were standing in front of our old maple tree. Both of them were in light blue overalls and white shirts with tiny flowers on them. Their hair was curled in the same soft waves, half pulled back with matching clips. They were holding hands, leaning their heads together, smiling like they had just been laughing really hard before someone snapped the shot.
    They looked beautiful.
    They looked coordinated.
    They looked like they belonged on a greeting card.
    I, on the other hand, was in my faded gray scrubs, with a coffee stain near the pocket and dark circles under my eyes from working the emergency room all night. My hair was in a messy bun that was more “fell apart at 3 a.m.” than “put together on purpose.” My sneakers had a hole near the toe that I kept meaning to fix.
    I am the mom who signs field trip forms the morning they are due, scribbling my name on the kitchen counter while Ellie is putting on her shoes. I am the mom who shows up at school concerts still smelling faintly of antiseptic because I did not have time to shower between my shift and her performance. I am the mom who has to borrow a blanket or a folding chair at soccer games because I always think of everything except the one thing I actually need.
    When my ex husband, Mark, told me he was getting remarried, it hit harder than I expected. I genuinely wanted him to be happy. Our marriage had burned out long before it ended, and we were better parents apart than we had been together. Still, when he told me about Mia, and I saw the first photos of her with Ellie, something in me sank.
    She teaches yoga and works part time from home. She bakes muffins on Tuesdays for no reason. She labels pantry containers in perfect handwriting. Her nails are painted. Her car is clean. Her hair looks smooth even in the rain.
    Ellie would come back from weekends at their house talking about “Miss Mia’s special pancakes” and “the really cool way Mia does bubble braids.” I would nod and smile and say, “That sounds fun,” while inside, a small frightened voice whispered, Is she going to love her more than me.
    The first time I saw Mia at a school event, I felt painfully ordinary standing next to her. It was the fall carnival. Ellie spotted us both at nearly the same moment and ran straight down the grassy hill with her arms open, shouting “You are both here.”
    We stood there, side by side, while Ellie bounced between us, tugging us toward the cotton candy line. I noticed the way Mia had a backpack with snacks, wipes, and a first aid kit. I had my wallet and a handful of tickets stuffed into my pocket.
    I tried not to resent her for being prepared.
    One night, after a particularly long shift and an extra long cry in the shower, I called my older sister, Dana. I told her everything. How every time Ellie mentioned Mia, a strange tightness settled in my chest. How I felt like a messy, tired, backup version of “mom” next to this seemingly effortless woman who had stepped into our lives with her gentle voice and neatly folded sweaters.
    “I know it is not logical,” I said, wiping my eyes with the sleeve of my sweatshirt. “I know love is not a competition, but I feel like I am losing at something.”
    Dana was quiet for a moment.
    “You know what I see,” she said finally. “I see a little girl who has more people to love her, not less. You are looking at this like you and Mia are on opposite teams. You are not. You are on the same side. You are not competing. You are completing.”
    The words landed in my ear and then in my heart, but they took time to sink in.
    Life went on. Ellie’s weeks started to take on a rhythm. Mondays and Tuesdays with me. Wednesdays after school at her dad’s house. Thursdays back at my place. Every other weekend shifting between homes. Art projects traveled in her backpack. Stuffed animals rotated. Sneakers migrated.
    Mia and I began texting more often. At first it was just logistics.
    “Ellie forgot her reading log, can I send you a picture of it.”
    “She has a dentist appointment Thursday, do you want me to take her or do you want to.”
    Then slowly, there were little kindnesses tucked in between the details.
    “I put the extra sweater in her bag, it looked chilly this morning.”
    “She said she misses your spaghetti, it is still her favorite.”
    One Saturday at a soccer game, I rushed straight from a delayed shift, apologizing breathlessly to no one in particular as I hurried across the field. I felt my stomach drop when I realized everyone else was seated and I had nothing to sit on.
    Mia caught my eye and lifted a foldable chair.
    “I brought an extra,” she called. “I thought you might still be at work and get here in a rush.”
    I took it from her and for the first time, instead of feeling lesser for needing help, I allowed myself to feel grateful. We sat side by side, yelling the same encouragements at the same small girl chasing the ball in the wrong direction.
    “Nice hustle, El,” we shouted together. Then we glanced at each other and laughed.
    Later that week, I took Ellie for ice cream after school. She swung her legs off the metal bench and said, “Can Mia come next time too.”
    The question hit me with a familiar sting, but this time it felt different.
    “Do you like it when we are all together,” I asked.
    She nodded enthusiastically. “You are good at finding silly things and making jokes,” she said. “And Mia is good at picking flavors and letting me try her spoon. You both make everything fun in different ways.”
    In that moment, I saw it through her eyes. She was not dividing us. She was combining us. Where I saw comparison, she saw addition.
    Small things shifted after that.
    When Ellie needed help with a school project and I was scheduled for three night shifts in a row, I asked Mia if she wanted to take the lead on the craft part. She lit up and said yes. She sent me photos of glitter and construction paper spread across the table. I helped Ellie practice her oral presentation in the living room the night before it was due, coaching her on breathing and eye contact.
    When there was a mother daughter breakfast at school on a Friday I could not get off work, I nearly dissolved into tears. I called Mark, apologizing over and over. “I hate missing these things,” I said. “I feel like I am failing her.”
    He was quiet for a second, then said, “Mia already took the morning off. She would be happy to go with her. They can FaceTime you if you get a break.”
    That morning, while I was charting in the staff lounge, my phone buzzed. Ellie’s face filled the screen, syrup on her cheek, paper plate full of pancakes in front of her. Mia waved from beside her.
    “Hi Mom,” Ellie said. “We put your name on the heart too. The paper said ‘someone who loves you’ and I wrote both of you.”
    Later, when I opened my locker at the hospital, I found a folded note tucked into my jacket pocket. It was from Mia.
    “Thank you for sharing her,” it said in neat handwriting. “She talks about how brave and strong you are all the time. You are the one who makes her believe she can do anything.”
    I sat on the little bench in the locker room and cried in the quiet, grateful tears instead of the bitter ones I had shed before.
    Our lives became a patchwork of small shared efforts.
    When Ellie needed a dress for a school concert, I took her shopping on my day off, and Mia met us at the mall after her class. We all stood in the dressing room hallway while Ellie tried on options, spinning in each one like the floor was a stage. Mia noticed the hemline. I noticed whether Ellie could still run in it. We picked the same dress at the same time.
    On Halloween, Ellie asked if “both my moms” could walk with her around the neighborhood. She said it like it was the most normal thing in the world. She held my hand on one side and Mia’s on the other, her candy bucket swinging between us.
    There are still moments when something sharp pricks at me. When Ellie casually mentions that Mia remembers to cut the crusts off her sandwiches just right. When I miss a school assembly because a patient takes a bad turn ten minutes before my shift ends. When I see a photo on social media of them doing something fun on a weekend that is not mine.
    In those moments, I hear Dana’s voice again. You are not competing. You are completing.
    I remind myself that there are things Ellie does with me that are ours. We have our late night grilled cheese sandwiches when I get home from an evening shift and she is still awake. We have our car concerts where we sing loudly and badly with the windows down. We have our Sunday morning smoothie experiments where we put way too many strawberries in the blender.
    Mia brings organization, calm, and creative projects that I would never think to try. I bring chaos, impulsive ice cream trips, and the kind of tired honesty that says, “I do not know the answer, but we will figure it out together.”
    We do not cancel each other out. We round each other out.
    Back in that parking lot outside the pharmacy, I looked again at the picture of Ellie and Mia in their matching outfits. My first thought that morning had been, “I could never pull that off.” Now, staring at it for the tenth time, a new thought slipped in.
    “She looks so loved.”
    Not “She looks more loved there than here.”
    Just loved.
    Every bedtime story read. Every soccer game watched. Every braid brushed. Every snack packed. Every ride to practice. Piece by piece, all of us are building the soft place she will fall back on when the world is hard.
    I typed out a reply before I could talk myself out of it.
    “They both look beautiful,” I wrote. “Thank you for doing her hair so nicely. She is going to be excited to show me later.”
    Mia responded almost immediately.
    “She picked the matching shirts,” she wrote. “She said, ‘Mom Lily likes when we send her funny pictures.’ She was thinking about you the whole time.”
    I set my phone down on the passenger seat and closed my eyes for a moment.
    This blended family thing still feels strange to explain to people. It is not perfect. There are awkward hand offs and schedule mix ups and moments when old wounds ache. It is a puzzle that does not look like the picture on the box, and yet somehow the pieces fit.
    The beauty of it is that my daughter does not spend time dividing her heart into careful portions. She simply loves. She is just lucky enough to have more than one adult who shows up for her, in different ways, on different days.
    She is not choosing between us.
    She is getting the gift of being loved twice.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    11 mins

    Share this content